What is "whistleblowing" in business ethics, and when is it considered morally justified?

Question

Accepted Answer

Disclosing illegal, unethical, or harmful organizational practices to authorities or the public when internal channels have failed to address the wrongdoing. Whistleblowing in business ethics involves an employee or insider reporting illegal, unethical, or harmful practices within their organization to internal authorities, external regulatory agencies, or the public. It is generally considered morally justified when the wrongdoing poses serious harm to others, when internal reporting channels have been exhausted or are inadequate, when the whistleblower has evidence to support their claims, and when the potential public benefit outweighs the harms of disclosure. Whistleblowing raises complex ethical tensions between loyalty to one's employer and the obligation to protect the public from harm.

Reporting on competitors' strategies describes corporate espionage or competitive intelligence, which is a form of unethical business conduct rather than the ethical act of exposing wrongdoing within one's own organization. Announcing financial results prematurely describes a potential securities violation (insider trading or selective disclosure) rather than the ethical act of reporting organizational misconduct. Using a whistle to signal the end of work is a literal interpretation that has no connection to the ethical concept of reporting organizational wrongdoing.

Whistleblowing is a significant topic on the Ethics in America DSST exam. Students should understand the ethical arguments for and against whistleblowing, the conditions under which it is morally justified, legal protections for whistleblowers (Sarbanes-Oxley Act, Dodd-Frank Act, Whistleblower Protection Act), and notable cases that have shaped American business ethics and regulation.

DSST Ethics in America: Question of the Day

Get a free DSST Ethics in America question every day

Ready for the full DSST Ethics in America? Earn 3 college credits.